This week: the many uses of mayonnaise, how to quickly make the best mayo you’ve ever had, transforming cherry tomatoes into three different intense ingredients, weird German bread, an 8-year-old teaches me to make emergency halvah, a good country kitchen song.

Covering The Spread

Here’s a roundup of things you can do with mayonnaise, one of the most versatile ingredients in your fridge. For complicated ethnocultural reasons, I grew up suspicious of mayo and I don’t think I knowingly ate any until I was maybe 15. This is silly, of course; mayonnaise makes almost any savory sandwich better. But it’s only in the last few years that I’ve also come to value it as a utility player in cooked food.

At heart mayonnaise is just eggs, oil, salt, and vinegar, so it makes sense that it’s as useful as those things are separately when you’re cooking. Right now I have three kinds in the fridge: a jar of Trader Joe’s house brand, a big squeezie of Kewpie, and a pint container of homemade. They’re all getting used this week. How?

  • Grilled cheese. Instead of spreading butter on your bread, use a thin layer of store-bought mayonnaise. You get way better browning with less risk of burning, and the mayonnaise tang cooks off. You still need butter for the pan, but mayo makes a superior crust.

  • Searing or grilling fish: Same principle as above—you just get a better surface for browning and less sticking than with oil alone. This works with roasted vegetables too.

  • Salad dressing: Somewhere between a dash and a tablespoon of mayo goes into pretty much every batch of salad dressing I make, and I make a lot of salad dressing. It enhances the flavor, but mostly it’s there to stabilize things and help the emulsification. Vinaigrettes stay unbroken way longer with mayonnaise in the mix.

  • Pan sauces: Just whisk a few spoonfuls into whatever’s left after you sear a chop or roast a chicken and you’ll get a creamy sauce to spoon over the meat.

  • Chocolate cake: Sounds nuts. But again, it’s mostly just eggs and oil! I think it genuinely makes a moister cake. (Quick side story that probably doesn’t help my case, but—When he was still learning fractions my younger son famously made a kids recipe for a snack cake that called for 2/3 cup of mayonnaise, but instead added 2 AND 1/3 CUPS of mayonnaise. You know this newsletter’s motto: We Still Ate It. And it was not bad!)

  • The usual mayonnaise stuff: I mean obviously—tomato sandwiches, drizzled over onokomiyaki, into aioli for anything fried, on grilled corn with lime, cotija, and Tajín. It makes everything better.

Kewpie mayonnaise is the best storebought mayonnaise for most cold uses—because it has MSG—but it turns weird and unfriendly when you cook with it. So keep an American-style mayo on hand also. But the very best mayonnaise is the kind you make yourself. If you have an immersion blender this takes one egg, some mustard, oil, lemon juice, garlic and literally two minutes and there’s no reason not to do it every time you run out. If you have never tried this I strongly suggest it.

(If you DON’T have an immersion blender you can still make mayo at home—here’s a video of Alton Brown explaining how in detail—but personally I’m not doing that regularly.)

Oh and, perhaps obviously, homemade mayonnaise involves eating raw eggs, so if you’re nervous about that you shouldn’t do it. There’s probably a way to pasteurize the eggs first. Worth a Google.

Black, white and yellow semi-abstract drawing of egg yolks.

Drawing by Isaac Langer.

Confit Your Tomatoes

It’s past the end of proper tomato season here in southern California, but there are still delicious cherry and grape tomatoes in the markets. I don’t love eating cherry tomatoes raw, but nearly every week in August and September I get a pint or two and confit them.

Here’s how: put rinsed tomatoes in a baking dish with peeled garlic cloves, some peppercorns, salt, bay leaf, and thyme or rosemary. Add olive oil to about halfway up the tomatoes, then bake in a low oven (275° F / 130° C) for an hour or so, stirring a few times throughout.

A small baking dish with small tomatoes, peeled garlic, and some bay leaves sitting on a wooden kitchen counter.

Tomatoes in a baking dish before adding oil. Forgot to take an “after” picture. Photo by Yossi Langer.

From this you get garlicky, tomatoey oil you can use for salads or just to drizzle on bread; soft, spreadable garlic cloves that you can, inter alia, stir into your mayonnaise; and, best of all, concentrated umami-bomb confit’d tomatoes for sandwiches, salads, pasta, whatever. Bake a slab of feta in the oil and then mix it into hot pasta with the tomatoes and garlic for a very easy dinner. The tomatoes are great with homemade mayonnaise on a sandwich with cold chicken, or tuna salad, or just some hard cheese.

(By the way, I always store the garlic cloves separately from the oil because of something I half-remember about food safety. You should probably do the same?)

If you’re still reading this, thank you! I hope it’s useful to you. Forward it to two other people you think might like it, and tell them to sign up to get these every week at heysimmerdown.com.

A Good Social Media Post About Food

A screenshot of a reddit post with a picture of an elaborately, multiply braided loaf of bread. A user has commented "is this biblically accurate Challah?"

Spotted on the r/Breadit subreddit. “Biblically accurate challah” is so good.

Some Things I Cooked This Week

The last of summer’s sugar snap peas with mint and walnuts; a dramatic soft yellow braided German butternut squash bread (pictured below); butternut squash soup with the roasted squash that didn’t go into the bread; some pesto. The squash bread is mild, but toasted with butter and a light drizzle of honey it comes into its own.

I know that normal people don’t have rotisseries for their grills but, well, I do, and I rotisseried two farmers’ market chickens, basted with butter and rosemary that, along with the chicken juices, dripped into a pan of potatoes, onions, and carrots I set up below the spit. It was so good. We’re still eating the leftovers, which are also so good.

Excavating the freezer I found a bag of frozen french fries that I turned into a snack with a combination microwave / air fryer method I’d been wanting to try—pretty good! We ate them with homemade mayonnaise! See above!

A yellowish round braided loaf studded with pumpkin seeds, sitting on a sheet tray on a wooden counter.

Braided German squash bread. Photo by Yossi Langer.

Something Somebody Else Cooked This Week

The most suprising cooking event of the week happened when my son’s 8-year-old friend strolled into the kitchen and announced he was going to make halva. He spooned out some tahini, added honey and a splash of water, and then mixed it like crazy. The result was a soft, spreadable halva—not the chewy stuff that requires you to heat up the honey and usually has pistachios and things in it, but a really good substitute and something I will definitely be experimenting with in the future.

This Week’s Kitchen Song

A kitchen song is a song I like to listen to in my kitchen.

“And I Haven’t Seen My Love in Quite a While” by This is Lorelei. Good peeling-potatoes song.

Letters To The Editor

Reader Katie writes: “… in response to your wowee tweet i saw someone suggest bringing two boiled eggs (unpeeled) with you as portable hand warmers you can eat later and thought that was brilliant.” Good stuff, thanks Katie!

Send questions complaints etc. to [email protected]

About Simmer Down

Simmer Down is a weekly newsletter about cooking real food at home for people who want to do that but think they’re too busy to, written by me, Yossi Langer, a busy person with kids in Los Angeles.

AI Usage Statement

I don’t use AI to write Simmer Down. Any emdashes are my own. I do use Claude to generate what’s called the SEO summary for the web version. This is not a statement of belief, just a personal preference: I’m writing this because I like to write. Any mistakes are my own.